They were fierce, feared, and bloodthirsty fighters. But they used that ferocity to kill and conquer other Africans for sale to slave traders.
The trans-Atlantic African and the Arab African slave trade could not have occurred without the complicity of African chiefs, who sold conquered Africans to European and Arab slavers.
In the film, white slavers are the enemy when, in reality, they were business partners with the "women kings."
Critic Robert Daniels, who mostly praised the film, said:
"You might wonder how (director Gina) Prince-Bythewood can shape a tale centering the Agojie warriors -- an all-woman group of soldiers known as the Amazons, sworn to honor and sisterhood -- hailing from the West African kingdom of Dahomey when one considers their hand in perpetuating the transatlantic slave trade."
A review on Last Movie Outpost, called "'The Woman King' Historical Embarrassment," puts it this way:
"The movie has been set up as having a historical basis, telling the story of the real-life Kingdom of Dahomey in the 18th and 19th centuries. ... In reality, Dahomey was a notorious slave kingdom, and not the Pan-African freedom fighters as the movie presents them. They enslaved and murdered hundreds of thousands from other tribes and sold them into the slave trade.
"Dahomey was renowned as the 'Black Sparta,' and was a fiercely militaristic society bent on domination and conquest. Their soldiers struck fear into other tribes all along what is still known as the Slave Coast, as they captured tribespeople from enemy tribes and sold them as slaves.
"The Dahomey women fought to protect their slave trade. Even worse for those who struggle with reality, the Amazons were formed from among the king's 'third class' wives. These were those considered insufficiently beautiful to share his bed and who had not borne children. Awkward!"
About the film, "History vs. Hollywood" writes:
"In real life, Dahomey is much more the villains than the heroes. ... They conquered neighboring African states and took their citizens as slaves, selling many in the Atlantic slave trade in exchange for items like rifles, tobacco, and alcohol. Many of the slaves they sold ended up in America. ... The business of slavery is what brought Dahomey most of its wealth. ... There are accounts of Dahomey warriors conducting slave raids on villages where they cut the heads off of the elderly and ripped the bottom jaw bones off others. During the raids, they'd burn the villages to the ground. Those who they let live, including the children, were taken captive, and sold as slaves."
So, will Africa reimburse American reparations-paying taxpayers?