By Gerard Baker | The Wall Street Journal
The
Great 2020 Meltdown has exposed the rottenness of our political and corporate
establishments.
The most intolerable irony of the past few miserable
months has been listening to our self-appointed moral leaders lecture us on
the nation’s irredeemable sinfulness from the comfort of their own secure,
well-upholstered positions, while we endure daily the urban nightmare of a world
created by their political allies.
As our cultural, media and corporate chiefs deliver their
social and political wisdom from their redoubts in New York’s Hamptons, Palm
Beach, Fla., and the greener pastures of the San Francisco Bay Area, America’s
cities have been ravaged by successive predations of lockdown, disorder and
violence.
Urban living is a fragile trade-off at the best of times
between convenience and discomfort, excitement and peril, opportunity and
expense. If you take away the convenience, excitement and opportunity, the
residue isn’t an appealing one.
For cities like New York, Chicago, Minneapolis, Seattle
and Portland, Ore., the damage done by this indulgent summer of insanity may
never be repaired. For decades these cities have been controlled by monolithic
Democratic establishments—though Republican mayors proved they could govern New
York. They have milked the more dynamic parts of their populations to feed
their own ideological agenda while doing nothing to lift the least advantaged
out of misery.
The Great Meltdown of 2020 has exposed how
rotten these urban establishments have become.
The lockdown, that soul-crushing exercise in economic
suicide, imposed and enforced largely by the people it least affects, has
permanently demolished vast elements of the economic base of these cities:
businesses that will never return, employees who have moved away or will work
from home rather than tolerate the increasingly perilous lottery of commuting
and working in a deteriorating urban environment.
Adding to the injury were weeks of unrestrained, anarchic
unrest, with whole parts of cities burned and blighted, with the willing
connivance, even encouragement, of authority.
Then, as Democratic mayors actively encouraged an all-out
assault on city police forces, a terrifying wave of violence and crime swept
the cities. In Chicago last month murder rose 139% over a year earlier. New
York had more shootings in the first seven months of 2020 than in all of 2019.
The victims of these crimes are almost never the vocal elites, safe in their
well-protected homes and offices. They are the poorest and least secure of our
neighbors.
Meanwhile, political leaders—backed with money and words
from their business allies—have responded with an elaborate performative
exercise that has nothing to offer the daily reality but is designed to redraw
the boundaries of our free thought. So, for example, those of us who stayed in
New York this summer weren’t permitted to worship in church, but we were
allowed—we were more or less instructed—to worship at the feet of those who
preach hatred of the police, racial strife and white self-loathing. Friends
weren’t permitted to attend parents’ funerals, but the right people were free
to travel across state lines to attend multiple funerals for political and
public show.
If you think irony is dead you had only to observe Bill
de Blasio, New York’s mayor, posing for pictures as he painted “Black Lives
Matter” on America’s most famous shopping street, while a few miles away his
city resonated to the sound of gunfire and the anguished cries of families of
children murdered in broad daylight.
This is what modern leadership looks like: a morality
play that treats us all like recalcitrant children, even as the cities we
helped build implode around us.
Whatever the political consequences of this unprecedented
summer, there will be hefty costs, and they won’t be borne by those
responsible. As cities are further hollowed out by crime and decay, taxes will
rise, further stifling investment and growth, further harming the most
disadvantaged, and accelerating a vicious circle of decline.
It’s a needless tragedy engineered by ideologues that is
sending into sharp reverse the gains made in large American cities in the early
years of the 21st century.
Already between 2015 and 2019, migration away from
America’ largest cities had accelerated. That was largely an economic phenomenon, as
rising taxes and the possibilities of technology drove people away. City
leaders are now re-creating the social conditions that ruined these cities in
the 1960s and ’70s: violent crime; urban blight, crumbling infrastructure. And
they’ve added to that list schools run by unions dedicated to radical ideology
and the mob in control of the streets in furtherance of an intolerant political
agenda.
Worst of all, now we have a corporate elite, safely
sequestered from the consequences of all this ruin, loudly helping it along by
signaling their own virtue and denouncing our supposed vice.
