BY PAUL MIRENGOFF | POWERLINE
Sullivan of the Washington Post has written a column with
the unwieldy title “‘Not racially motivated’?: The Atlanta spa shootings show
why the media should be wary of initial police statements.” Actually, the
shootings demonstrate, for the millionth time, that the public should be wary
of mainstream media statements.
The initial police statement about the shootings was that
they did not appear to be racially motivated. Instead, they were the result
of “what [the killer] considers a sex addiction.” “He sees these locations
[message parlors] as something that allows him to go to these places and it’s a
temptation for him that he wanted to eliminate,” the police explained.
The mainstream media quickly rejected this explanation.
It insisted that the killings were racially motivated. They were the symptom of
rampant anti-Asian sentiment fueled, to a significant degree, by
former President Trump. Seizing on the Atlanta shootings, the
Post has for days been running article after article about “hate crimes”
directed at Asian-Americans
Monica Hess of the Post tried to counter the “sex
addiction” explanation this
[The killer] could have stopped at strip
clubs, pornographic video stores or multiple shops lined with wall-to-wall
dildoes. But he didn’t. He drove 27 miles to Gold Spa, where he allegedly
killed three Asian women, and then crossed the street to Aromatherapy Spa where
he allegedly killed one more (the names of the victims at the final two
establishments have not been released).
He chose businesses where the employees were
not just women, but Asian women, not just Asian women, but lower-wage Asian
women in a fetishized profession.
It seems, however, that the shooter drove to these
“spas” because they were ones
he had patronized. If that’s true, then
the shooter’s choice of locations is fully consistent with the theory that he
was motivated by guilt over sex. It neither supports nor refutes the suggestion
of bias against Asians.
Other evidence strongly supports the “sex addiction”
theory. According to USA
Today, the killer “had been in rehab for sex addiction and was
wracked with guilt about his sexual urges, according to two people who lived
with him in transitional housing.” Moreover, he “was deeply religious and could
not control his desire to visit massage parlors and engage in sexual acts,
something that sent him into deep bouts of depression.” (Emphasis
What evidence, other than the identity of the victims,
backs up the view that racial basis motivated the killings? None of which I’m
aware. And it’s worth noting, as John
Sexton does, that a highly-publicized attack on an
elderly Asian man in Oakland by a black suspect has
not been charged as murder even though the family believes race was clearly a
Both of the killer’s housemates say they
never heard him use racist language or disparage non-white people. Both say he
was rarely online and, to their knowledge, didn’t frequent racist internet
message boards or websites. Two former high school classmates added that he
didn’t express political opinions in public and was not overtly racist.
Does the fact that the shooter chose to patronize Asian
message parlors show some form of anti-Asian animus? I don’t think such animus
can be inferred from the source of his efforts to achieve sexual gratification.
In fact, according again to USA Today, the shooter told his housemates that
he preferred these massage parlors because “he thought the spas were safer than
paying for sex elsewhere.”
As the matter is investigated further, perhaps evidence
will emerge supporting the media’s conclusion that the shooter was a racist
whose deadly actions were motivated by hatred of Asians. As of now, though,
this view lacks support. By contrast, the “sex addiction” theory has a solid
So why has the media adopted the “hate crime” narrative?
That’s an easy one. As Liz
Sheld of American Greatness says, the media
is bent on “sowing suspicion and division among Americans.”
When bad things happen, it will always pick the explanation that casts
Americans in the worst, most racist light, even if a more plausible alternative
is staring us in the face.
As will Democrats, including Joe
Morning Greatness: Atlanta Massage Parlor
Assassin Felt Guilty Over Sex Addiction
By Liz Sheld |
The progressive activist-media cartel is highly invested
in the narrative that white supremacists are on an Asian-American violence
rampage. A string of murders in the Atlanta area is the latest opportunity to
sing their racism siren song loud and clear for their target audience.
I’m not going to name the homicidal maniac, but on
Tuesday, a young white male killed 8 people in a murder spree and 6 of the
victims were of Asian descent. But that’s not the only common thread in all the
slaughters: all of the locations were massage parlors/spas. This seems
important. Did the shooter have an problem with Asian Americans or did
he have a problem with massage parlors? Both seem plausible.
It turns out, the
shooter had a sex problem. According to USA Today,
the maniac “had been in rehab for sex addiction and was wracked with guilt
about his sexual urges, according to two people who lived with him in
transitional housing.” The report continues, he “was deeply religious and could
not control his desire to visit massage parlors and engage in sexual acts,
something that sent him into deep bouts of depression, said Tyler Bayless, who
lived with [SHOOTER] for six months in 2019 and 2020 at Maverick Recovery
Center in Roswell, Georgia. [SHOOTER] would frequently relapse, then express
guilt because of his Christian faith, Bayless said.” Additionally, the
perpetrator told the authorities he had a problem with his sexual urges. “He
has an issue that he considers a sex addiction and sees these locations as
something that allows him to go to these places,” said
Capt. Jay Baker, of the Cherokee County Sheriff’s Office.
“It’s a temptation for him that he wanted to eliminate.”
And there’s more:
Both Lillemon and Bayless said they had never
heard [SHOOTER] use racist language or disparage non-white people.
Both former housemates said [SHOOTER] spent remarkably
little time online, and to their knowledge didn’t frequent racist internet
message boards or websites.
“He didn’t even have a smartphone,” Bayless
Two former high school classmates said
[SHOOTER] was extremely shy. He didn’t voice his political opinions in public,
and wasn’t ever overtly racist, they said.
It’s fair to say his guilt over his sexual addiction is a
very likely motive, but alas, it is not useful to the activist-media cartel
invested in sowing suspicion and division among Americans so the narrative will
continue that racism is the animating factor in violent crime.
men were arrested in connection with an attack on an
elderly Asian gentlemen in a San Francisco laundromat. “The suspects have been
identified as 19-year-old Calvin Berschell, 19-year-old Jason Orozco, and
19-year-old Nolowde Beshears, all Antioch residents.” No mention of the
suspects’ race in the media reports. Here’s
a story about an elderly Asian woman in San Francisco who fought back against
an attacker and the suspect, who has been arrested,
is also suspected of an attack on an 83 year-old Asian man. No mention of the
suspect’s race. The public cannot look online to find mugshots of the suspects
because the San Francisco police has
stopped releasing booking photos online, claiming, WAIT
FOR IT, racial bias.
So, the activist-media cartel comes in strong with the
white racism angle, followed by “experts” talking for days about the violence
and shaming white people for their racism, arrests are made and we never hear
about who the attackers are. Lather, rinse, repeat. I’m in no way minimizing
the seriousness of these crimes, violent people need to be prosecuted and
punished. Period. I don’t care who the perpetrators are. But
the fact that the media is not closing the deal on the white racism narrative
is certainly suspicious.
And that’s all I’ve got, now go beat back the angry mob!
Sheld is the senior news editor at American Greatness. She is a veteran
political strategist and pollster who has worked on campaigns and public
interest affairs. Liz has written at Breitbart and The
Federalist, as well as at PJ
Media, where she wrote "The Morning Briefing." In her spare
time, she shoots sporting clays and watches documentaries.